Skip to content
Jakub Orłowskiadvocate+48 536 888 161Discuss your case

Appeal and cassation in Poland. Deadlines first.

A judgment can be challenged, but only within short and strict time limits. Missing the first of them, the request for written reasons, usually closes the way to an appeal.

The calendar after a first instance judgment

  1. 7 days: request for written reasons. Counted from the announcement of the judgment. Without this request you will not receive the reasons and the time to appeal will not open for you.
  2. 14 days: the appeal. Counted from the day the judgment with its written reasons is served on you or your lawyer.
  3. The appeal hearing. The higher court examines the judgment within the limits of the appeal and the objections raised in it.

These time limits are final. A day’s delay normally means the appeal is not accepted.

What a good appeal does

An appeal is not a repetition of the closing speech. It has to name specific errors: in the findings of fact, in the assessment of evidence, in the procedure, in the application of the law or in the sentence. Each objection should point to a place in the file and explain how the error affected the outcome.

My work on an appeal starts with reading the reasons against the record of the trial. I check what the court relied on, what it left out and whether the reasoning holds together. Only then do we choose which objections to raise, because five strong ones carry more weight than twenty weak ones.

Cassation to the Supreme Court

A cassation is available against a final judgment of the appeal court.

  • Who drafts it. It must be prepared and signed by an advocate or an attorney at law. A party cannot file it personally.
  • Deadline. 30 days from service of the appellate judgment with reasons. The request for those reasons has to be made within 7 days.
  • Grounds. Only the gravest procedural defects listed in the code or another flagrant breach of law, if it could have had a significant impact on the content of the judgment.
  • Limits. As a rule the defence may file a cassation only when a prison sentence without suspension was imposed. The exception concerns the gravest procedural defects.

Before drafting, I prepare an analysis of whether there are grounds for a cassation at all. Sometimes the honest answer is that there are none, and it is better to know that before the deadline than after.

If you do not speak Polish

A judgment that can be appealed should be served on you with a translation. If you received documents only in Polish, or if you did not have an interpreter at the hearing, tell your lawyer. Depending on the circumstances this may itself be an argument in the appeal.

You will find more detail on the Polish pages about appeals and cassation.

Questions and answers

I was not present when the judgment was announced. Has the deadline passed?

Not necessarily. In some situations the time limit runs from the day the judgment is served and not from its announcement. If a deadline was missed for reasons beyond your control, a request to restore it can be filed within 7 days from the moment the obstacle ceased. This needs to be checked in the file quickly.

Can a new lawyer take over at the appeal stage?

Yes. An appeal is a separate piece of work based on the file, the recordings of the hearings and the written reasons. A lawyer who did not act at first instance reads the case with fresh eyes, which often helps.

Can the appeal court make the sentence harsher?

As a rule, only if the prosecutor or another party acting against the accused has also appealed. If the judgment is challenged only in favour of the accused, the court cannot rule to their disadvantage.

Is a cassation a third instance?

No. The Supreme Court does not hear the case again and does not reassess evidence. It checks whether the gravest procedural defects occurred or whether the law was breached in a flagrant way that could have had a significant impact on the judgment. A cassation cannot be based solely on the claim that the sentence is too severe.

Tell me where the case stands.

Give me the stage of the proceedings and the nearest deadline. We will agree what help you need and which documents to prepare.

I work in Polish and English. Scope and fee are agreed before any work starts.